The Emotions Behind Discovering the Truth About Santa

A Study Reveals Surprising Reactions from Children and Adults

For generations, the myth of Santa Claus has captivated the hearts and imaginations of children around the world. The idea of a jolly man in a red suit delivering presents on Christmas Eve has been a cherished tradition for many families. But what happens when children inevitably learn the truth? A recent study conducted by psychologists sheds light on the emotional responses of both children and adults upon discovering that Santa Claus is not real. The findings challenge our assumptions and provide valuable insights for parents navigating this delicate revelation.

A Mix of Emotions: Relief, Pride, and Betrayal

The study revealed a surprising range of emotions experienced by both children and adults upon learning the truth about Santa Claus. Contrary to popular belief, about half of the children and 20 percent of adults reported feeling positive about discovering the truth. Some expressed relief, finally finding resolution to their lingering doubts, while others felt a sense of pride, as if they had solved a complex puzzle. Interestingly, the research indicated that individuals who figured out the truth through logical reasoning or observation experienced less negative emotional associations compared to those who learned abruptly or through direct disclosure by others.

The Role of Reasoning and Observation

Children who discovered that Santa Claus is not real through logical reasoning or observation reported a more positive emotional response. Logical reasoning included recognizing the impossibility of Santa traveling to millions of homes in one night, while observation involved noticing that the wrapping paper on Santa’s gifts matched the ones in their parents’ closet. Similarly, adults who gradually pieced together the truth through logical reasoning or observation were less likely to have negative emotional associations compared to those who were told directly by peers or siblings.

Recommendations for Parents

Based on the study’s findings, the researchers offer three recommendations to help parents navigate the delicate conversation surrounding the truth about Santa Claus.

Firstly, parents should respect their child’s growing independence of mind. As children get older, discussing Santa becomes trickier. Most children discover the truth around the age of 7 or 8, but the timing varies. The study found that children who were on the older side, closer to 11 or 12, when they learned the truth were more likely to experience negative emotions.

Secondly, parents should actively listen to their child’s questions and ensure they understand what their child is asking before responding. Instead of immediately resorting to lying or giving up the game, parents can engage their child by asking what they think or discussing different beliefs about Santa Claus. This approach encourages critical thinking and allows children to explore their own ideas.

Lastly, even if a child has a negative experience upon learning the truth, it is not the end of the world. Some children may be more sensitive to being lied to about Santa Claus. The study found that a small subset of adults experienced negative emotions that lasted over a year after discovering the truth. These individuals felt betrayed by their parents and struggled with the perceived hypocrisy of being taught not to lie while being deceived about Santa Claus.


The emotions surrounding the revelation of Santa Claus’s non-existence are complex and varied. While some children and adults experience negative emotions, others find relief and pride in uncovering the truth. By respecting children’s growing independence, listening to their questions, and acknowledging their feelings, parents can navigate this delicate conversation with sensitivity. Ultimately, the study reminds us that the discovery of Santa Claus’s myth is not solely about the loss of childhood innocence but also an opportunity for growth and critical thinking.






Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *