NYU Professor Urges Newsrooms to Prioritize the Stakes of the Presidential Contest
As the 2024 elections loom closer, the need for newsrooms to shift their focus from the horse race to the stakes of the presidential contest has become increasingly urgent. Jay Rosen, a journalism professor at New York University, has been advocating for this change, emphasizing the importance of highlighting the potential consequences for American democracy. With a candidate like Donald Trump, who has incited an insurrection, been impeached twice, and faced multiple indictments, the stakes are higher than ever. This article explores the necessity of prioritizing the stakes over the horse race, the challenges faced by news organizations, and the encouraging signs of change in coverage.
The Urgency of the Stakes:
Rosen stresses that the stakes of the 2024 election go beyond the usual political contest. The very fabric of American democracy is at risk, making it crucial for newsrooms to focus on what might happen as a result of the election. Trump’s language and behavior echo that of authoritarian leaders, revealing his plans for a potential second term. With democracy on the line, there is an urgency to shift the narrative and delve into the potential consequences for the country during and after a second Trump presidency.
The Pitfalls of Horse Race Coverage:
Critics of the media often argue that political coverage focuses too much on the ups and downs of the horse race, neglecting policy discussions and the impact a victor might have on the world. Horse race coverage allows news organizations to avoid thorny issues and controversial rhetoric, potentially avoiding accusations of bias. However, Rosen argues that this approach is insufficient given the gravity of the current political climate. While horse race coverage can create excitement and suspense, it should not be the primary focus or organizing principle of campaign coverage.
The Shift Towards Stakes Journalism:
There are signs that news organizations are beginning to prioritize the stakes of the 2024 election. Major outlets like The New York Times, The Washington Post, and the Associated Press have published detailed stories on Trump’s alarming plans should he be re-elected. Cable news networks like CNN and MSNBC have also dedicated segments to discussing these issues. This shift towards stakes journalism is encouraging, as it highlights the potential consequences and helps inform the public about the risks associated with a second Trump presidency.
Conclusion:
With less than a year until the 2024 elections, newsrooms must prioritize the stakes of the presidential contest over the horse race. The potential consequences for American democracy are too significant to be overshadowed by polling and political strategy. While horse race coverage still has its place in reporting, it should not be the primary focus or organizing principle of campaign coverage. The shift towards stakes journalism, as evidenced by major news outlets, is a positive sign that newsrooms are recognizing the urgency of the situation. By highlighting the stakes, news organizations can provide a more comprehensive and informed perspective to the public, ensuring that voters are aware of the potential impact of their choices in the upcoming election.
Leave a Reply