President Laurentino Cortizo announces the closure of Cobre Panama following the Supreme Court’s ruling, amid public anger and protests against the generous contract.
Panama’s president, Laurentino Cortizo, declared on Tuesday that the Cobre Panama copper mine operated by Canadian miner First Quantum would be shut down. This announcement came shortly after the country’s Supreme Court declared the contract between First Quantum and the Panamanian government unconstitutional. The ruling has ignited public anger, leading to street protests that initially focused on environmental concerns but have since expanded to encompass broader grievances against the government. First Quantum has suspended commercial production at the mine and is now preparing for international arbitration, although it hopes to engage in pre-arbitration talks with the Panamanian government to avoid a lengthy legal process.
Public Outrage and Suspension of Production
The Cobre Panama mine has been a source of public anger in Panama, with citizens expressing their discontent through protests. Initially, the demonstrations centered around environmental concerns related to the mine’s operations. However, the protests have evolved into broader expressions of dissatisfaction with the government, fueled by allegations that the contract with First Quantum was excessively favorable to the company. In response to the Supreme Court’s ruling, First Quantum has suspended commercial production at the mine and is transitioning it into a state of care and maintenance.
Legal Implications and International Arbitration
The Supreme Court’s ruling has placed First Quantum on a path towards international arbitration, a process that can be lengthy and unpredictable. However, the company has indicated its willingness to engage in pre-arbitration talks with the Panamanian government in an effort to find a resolution without resorting to formal legal proceedings. The disputed contract, which was agreed upon just last month, granted First Quantum a 20-year mining right with the option to extend for another 20 years, in exchange for annual revenue of $375 million for Panama.
Unconstitutional Contract and Company Response
The Supreme Court’s President, Maria Eugenia Lopez, declared the entire law 406, which encompassed the contract, unconstitutional. First Quantum acknowledged the ruling and emphasized its commitment to regulatory compliance in all aspects of its operations in Panama. Protester groups on social media have expressed their intention to continue demonstrating until the ruling is officially published in the country’s official gazette.
Economic and Political Ramifications
The closure of Cobre Panama will have significant economic consequences for both First Quantum and Panama. The mine currently accounts for approximately 1% of global copper production, and its closure could impact the copper market. Furthermore, Cobre Panama contributes about 5% to Panama’s GDP, making it a crucial business for the country. J.P. Morgan warned that if the contract was revoked, the likelihood of Panama losing its investment-grade rating would increase significantly. The opposition to the contract has also become a central issue in Panama’s upcoming presidential election, with candidates advocating for greater state control over the mine.
Negotiations and the Future of the Mine
First Quantum’s Panama unit has expressed its willingness to engage in constructive dialogue regarding the mining contract before determining its course of action. However, a bill enacted by Panama’s government in November has effectively banned all new mining concessions and extensions, potentially hindering the possibility of negotiations for a new deal. Presidential candidate Ricardo Martinelli has proposed renegotiating the contract to secure higher royalties and a stake in the project. It remains to be seen how the situation will unfold and whether a resolution can be reached.
Conclusion: The Supreme Court’s ruling declaring First Quantum’s contract for the Cobre Panama mine unconstitutional has led to the shutdown of the lucrative copper mine. This decision comes after public protests and broader dissatisfaction with the government’s handling of the contract, which was perceived as overly generous to the Canadian mining company. The closure of the mine will have significant economic and political ramifications for both First Quantum and Panama. The company now faces the prospect of international arbitration, while Panama must grapple with the loss of a major contributor to its GDP. The outcome of this dispute will have far-reaching implications for the mining industry and the political landscape of Panama.
Leave a Reply