Kliph Nesteroff’s “Outrageous” and Jesse David Fox’s “Comedy Book” Shed Light on the Historical Challenges of Comedy and the Modern Climate of Sensitivity
In an era marked by cancel culture and heightened sensitivity, many comedians have expressed frustration about the challenges of being funny in today’s climate. However, two new books, Kliph Nesteroff’s “Outrageous: A History of Showbiz and the Culture Wars” and Jesse David Fox’s “Comedy Book: How Comedy Conquered Culture — and the Magic That Makes It Work,” offer a fresh perspective on the subject. By examining the historical context and delving into the intricacies of comedy, these books challenge the notion that there has never been a worse time to express oneself through humor. In doing so, they shed light on the evolution of comedy and provide valuable insights into the current cultural landscape.
The Perpetual State of Despair
Nesteroff’s “Outrageous” takes readers on a journey through the history of showbiz, revealing a common thread of American entertainers’ perpetual state of despair over the censorious climate of their time. From Steve Allen’s complaints about the “very touchy times” in 1955 to Jerry Seinfeld being warned away from college performances due to students’ sensitivities in 2015, Nesteroff demonstrates that concerns about censorship and outrage are not exclusive to the present. By examining vintage letters to the editor, Nesteroff reveals that the sentiments expressed then are remarkably similar to those seen on social media today. This historical perspective challenges the notion that the current climate is uniquely oppressive.
Embracing the Backlash
In “Comedy Book,” Fox, a senior editor at New York magazine’s Vulture and an experienced interviewer of comedians, argues that the risk of backlash is an integral part of comedy. He likens it to the challenge of holding a ball while running for a touchdown, stating that it is the very essence of the game. Fox contends that political correctness may make comedy harder to do, but it also adds an element of excitement and tension. By embracing the potential for controversy, comedians can push boundaries and create thought-provoking humor. Fox’s perspective offers a refreshing take on the relationship between comedy and political correctness, urging readers to view it as a catalyst for innovation rather than a hindrance.
The Magic of Comedy
Both books delve into the magical quality of comedy and its ability to conquer culture. Nesteroff’s historical analysis highlights the resilience of comedy throughout the ages, demonstrating how it has always found a way to adapt and thrive despite societal challenges. From vaudeville to late-night television, comedy has constantly evolved, reflecting and shaping the cultural landscape. Fox’s exploration of the art form further emphasizes this transformative power. By examining the techniques and strategies employed by comedians, he uncovers the underlying mechanisms that make comedy work. From timing and delivery to the use of irony and satire, Fox reveals the intricate craftsmanship behind a well-crafted joke.
Conclusion:
In a time when comedians often feel constrained by the fear of backlash and cancel culture, Nesteroff’s “Outrageous” and Fox’s “Comedy Book” provide valuable insights and historical context. These books challenge the notion that there has never been a worse time for comedy, reminding us that entertainers have always faced challenges and that comedy has always found a way to prevail. By embracing the risk of controversy and understanding the underlying mechanics of humor, comedians can continue to push boundaries and create meaningful, thought-provoking comedy. Ultimately, these books invite readers to reconsider their perspectives on cancel culture and appreciate the transformative power of comedy in shaping our culture.
Leave a Reply