Tyler Cowen’s groundbreaking book delves into the history of economic thought, challenging conventional notions of greatness.
In his latest book, “GOAT: Who is the Greatest Economist of all Time, and Why Does it Matter?”, renowned economist Tyler Cowen takes readers on a captivating journey through the annals of economic history. Cowen’s book, available online for free, offers a unique perspective on the subject, combining breadth and depth with a touch of personal flair. This article will explore the key themes and insights from Cowen’s book, shedding light on the criteria used to determine the greatest economists of all time and the relevance of their work in today’s world.
The Genesis of a Pandemic Project
As the world grappled with the challenges posed by the pandemic, Cowen found himself seeking a project that could be pursued within the confines of his own library and online resources. The idea of a book on the history of economic thought emerged, offering a timeless topic that could never go obsolete. Inspired by books like Heilbroner’s “The Worldly Economists” and Bill Simmons’ “Book of Basketball,” Cowen set out to create a book that would teach readers how to appreciate the contributions of economists throughout history.
The Significance of the History of Economic Thought
While some may dismiss the history of economic thought as irrelevant, Cowen argues that recent successful books on economists like Keynes and Friedman indicate a genuine interest in the subject. By examining the past, we gain valuable insights into the development of economic ideas and their impact on society. Cowen’s book aims to bridge the gap between academia and the general public, presenting the history of economic thought as an engaging and accessible topic.
The Criteria for the Greatest Economist of All Time
In determining the greatest economist of all time (GOAT), Cowen establishes a set of criteria that includes breadth and depth of work, accuracy in economic analysis, historical significance, and contributions to both microeconomics and macroeconomics. While acknowledging the subjectivity inherent in such a task, Cowen sets out to identify individuals who meet these criteria and have left an indelible mark on the field of economics.
Marx and the Absence of the Semifinalists
Notably absent from Cowen’s list of finalists is Karl Marx, a figure often regarded as one of the greatest economists. Cowen argues that Marx’s numerous errors and his failure to meet the criteria for breadth and depth prevent him from being considered GOAT. However, Cowen hints at the possibility of a separate monograph dedicated solely to Marx, acknowledging his enduring influence and the need for a more nuanced exploration of his ideas.
The Semifinalists: Samuelson, Marshall, Arrow, Becker, and Schumpeter
Among the semifinalists, Paul Samuelson stands out for his wide-ranging contributions to the field. However, Cowen highlights Samuelson’s flawed understanding of actual economies, particularly his optimistic views on Soviet economic growth and his erroneous analyses of price controls and the Phillips Curve. Cowen also takes into account Samuelson’s reputation for not being particularly kind to his peers, a factor that influences his overall assessment.
The Finalists: Friedman, Keynes, Hayek, Smith, Malthus, and Mill
Cowen’s six finalists for the title of GOAT include Milton Friedman, John Maynard Keynes, F.A. Hayek, Adam Smith, Thomas Malthus, and John Stuart Mill. Each economist is evaluated based on their contributions to the field and their lasting impact. Cowen highlights their individual strengths and weaknesses, providing readers with a comprehensive understanding of their work.
In “GOAT: Who is the Greatest Economist of all Time, and Why Does it Matter?”, Tyler Cowen challenges readers to reconsider their preconceived notions of greatness in economics. By exploring the history of economic thought and evaluating economists based on a set of criteria, Cowen sheds light on the enduring relevance of their ideas and the lessons they offer for today’s world. While the debate over the greatest economist of all time may never reach a definitive conclusion, Cowen’s book serves as a valuable resource for understanding the evolution of economic thinking and its impact on society.
Leave a Reply