LGBTQ+ Representation in TV and Film: The Good, the Indirect, and the Bad

Exploring the Impact of LGBTQ+ Representation in Entertainment

Over the years, LGBTQ+ representation in television and film has become increasingly prominent. This progress has been crucial in normalizing queer characters and storylines, but it hasn’t always been executed well. While some projects have successfully incorporated LGBTQ+ representation, others have faced criticism for perpetuating stereotypes or mishandling queer storylines. In this article, we will explore examples of both good and bad LGBTQ+ representation in TV and film, highlighting the importance of authentic and thoughtful portrayals.

The Good:

“Will & Grace” (1998): This groundbreaking series featured openly gay characters at a time when LGBTQ+ representation was not widely accepted. Despite facing some criticism for stereotypical portrayals, the show played a significant role in normalizing the presence of gay characters on television.

“But I’m a Cheerleader” (1999): This comedy film, starring Natasha Lyonne, tells the story of a closeted lesbian cheerleader sent to a conversion camp. Although parts of the film have not aged well, it remains a beloved queer classic and a testament to early LGBTQ+ representation.

“Heartstopper” (Netflix): Based on the Alice Oseman webcomics, this series follows a cast of primarily LGBTQ+ characters navigating the challenges of their teenage years. Known for its authentic portrayal of queer characters, “Heartstopper” has gained popularity for its unique art style and compelling storytelling.

“Bottoms”: This hilarious comedy film follows two lesbian best friends who create an all-female fight club to get closer to their crushes. With its genuine LGBTQ+ representation, “Bottoms” offers a fun and inclusive watch.

Indirect Representation:

“Schitt’s Creek”: This hit comedy series features Dan Levy as David Rose, a pansexual character whose storyline extends beyond his sexuality. “Schitt’s Creek” demonstrates that LGBTQ+ characters can have multifaceted roles in a show, rather than being defined solely by their sexual orientation.

“The Morning Show”: While not initially centered around LGBTQ+ representation, this Apple TV+ series introduces a sapphic relationship between Reese Witherspoon’s Bradley Jackson and Julianna Margulies’ Laura Peterson. The representation is well-executed, blending seamlessly with other plotlines and adding depth to the characters.

“Booksmart”: Olivia Wilde’s coming-of-age comedy includes excellent LGBTQ+ representation that is not the main focus of the film. The story follows two best friends preparing to graduate, one of whom happens to be gay, subtly touching on the topic without overshadowing the overall narrative.

The Bad:

“They/Them”: This failed LGBTQ+ slasher film set in a conversion camp falls flat in its attempt at representation. The depictions of gay characters are stereotypical and the ending contains homophobic undertones, highlighting the dangers of poor execution.

“Riverdale”: While the show incorporates LGBTQ+ characters, their portrayals often rely on stereotypes and problematic representations. In season one, a heterosexual female kiss is used for shock value, exemplifying the show’s misguided attempt at queer representation.

“Pretty Little Liars”: Although the show includes an LGBTQ+ relationship, it feels forced and falls into the harmful trope of “bury your gays.” The portrayal of Emily Fields’ relationship with Maya is problematic, and the handling of homophobia within her family is poorly executed.

“Orange Is the New Black”: While the series showcases some positive LGBTQ+ representation, the portrayal of Piper Chapman’s bisexuality has been criticized for bisexual erasure. The character’s sexuality is presented as a binary choice between being gay or straight, erasing the existence of bisexuality.

Conclusion:

LGBTQ+ representation in TV and film plays a vital role in promoting inclusivity and acceptance. While many projects have successfully incorporated authentic and thoughtful portrayals of queer characters, others have fallen short, perpetuating stereotypes or mishandling LGBTQ+ storylines. It is essential for creators to approach LGBTQ+ representation with care and respect, ensuring that it reflects the diverse experiences of the community. By doing so, entertainment can continue to make a positive impact on society and foster greater understanding and acceptance for all.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *