Exploring the impact of assimilationist approaches on students from diverse backgrounds and the importance of creating inclusive classroom cultures.
Growing up as the child of Indian immigrants in predominantly white schools, I always felt the pressure to assimilate and conform. The lack of representation and the prevalence of insulting stereotypes made it difficult to find my place. However, it was this feeling of difference that ultimately led me to connect with others who shared a similar experience. Now, as an educator, I am confronted with the challenge of creating a classroom culture that embraces diversity and fosters inclusion.
A Tale of Two Students:
Reflecting on a recent transfer student’s adjustment to my classroom, I am reminded of a situation I encountered years ago. Two students, one white and one Black, displayed different reactions when reprimanded for talking in line. The white student apologized while the Black student questioned and defended their actions. This stark contrast made me question whether my responses were influenced by the students’ race or their reactions. It became apparent that the cultural patterns I had adopted from my own schooling experiences centered on behaviors deemed appropriate by the dominant culture, inadvertently marginalizing those who didn’t conform.
The Culture Our Choices Create:
As I observe my new student’s behavior, I realize that his actions are not uncommon for fifth graders. However, the identity of the student plays a significant role in how I interpret and respond to their behavior, as well as how their classmates perceive it. While I understand the need for flexibility and understanding, I also question the message this sends to the rest of the class. Does it reinforce biases and perpetuate a sense of otherness? These complex questions highlight the need to reinvent our practices and create more equitable schools.
Finding the Right Path:
Drawing inspiration from “Stamped” by Jason Reynolds and Ibram X Kendi, I have introduced my students to the concepts of segregationists, assimilationists, and anti-racists. This framework has helped me analyze my own choices and recognize how schools often assimilate students into the dominant culture. While this approach may seem logical, it may contribute to racial disparities in educational outcomes. It is crucial to move beyond assimilation and accept students for who they are, embracing their individual identities and cultures.
Making the Commitment:
My school district has made a commitment to equity, but addressing these issues in day-to-day situations remains a challenge. The lack of opportunities to interrogate the dominant culture and explore the racial contexts of our decisions hinders progress. As white educators, we must acknowledge our role in upholding a system that asks students of color to conform to a culture that may not fully embrace them. Recognizing the impact of race in our classrooms is the first step towards creating a more inclusive environment.
Conclusion:
Navigating classroom culture requires a paradigm shift from assimilation to inclusion. Educators must challenge the dominant cultural practices that marginalize students and instead affirm their individuality and multiple ways of being. By embracing diversity and fostering inclusion, we can co-create a classroom culture that celebrates the uniqueness of each student. This small act of resistance is a step towards the inclusive environment my younger self longed for, and it is a necessary step in creating equitable schools for all.
Leave a Reply